15 Astounding Must-Read True Crime Books

By Jessica Dukes and Matthew Thompson
True Crime Books

For decades, newspaper reporters and pamphleteers reported the sensational crimes of the day. But when In Cold Blood was published in 1966, it set a higher standard for the long-form, narrative true crime books that are so popular now. See why this book and the true-story thrillers that followed make it such a readable genre.

In Cold Blood: A True Account of a Multiple Murder and Its Consequences

By Truman Capote

On the trail of a good story, Capote (and his friend, Harper Lee) traveled to Holcomb, Kansas to study the unsolved murder of the Clutter family. The result: a page-turning thriller that traces the police investigation and eventual capture of Richard Hickock and Perry Smith, two men recently paroled from Kansas State Penitentiary. One year after Hickock and Smith’s execution, Capote published In Cold Blood—an overnight sensation and the second-best-selling true crime book of all time, second only to Helter Skelter.

Helter Skelter: The True Story of the Manson Murders

By Vincent Bugliosi and Curt Gentry

Published in 1974, Bugliosi was a prosecutor in the 1970 trial against Charles Manson. The book takes readers inside the courtroom where Manson’s crimes are laid out in agonizing detail. The murder of Rosemary and Leno LaBianca as well as pregnant actress, Sharon Tate, shocked the country and established Manson as a real-life supervillain.

A Death in Belmont

By Sebastian Junger

It’s the early 1960s, and the Boston Strangler is on the loose. In Junger’s hometown of Belmont, a man named Roy Smith is arrested, suspected of being the Strangler. On that very day, there’s a carpenter working at Junger’s house—Albert DeSalvo, who eventually confesses to being the real Boston Strangler. A Death in Belmont is the unbelievable story of how their three lives overlap.

The Wicked Boy: The Mystery of a Victorian Child Murderer

By Kate Summerscale

In 1895, Robert Coombes, age 13, is arrested for stabbing his mother to death. He easily confesses but offers no motive, so he is found guilty, yet insane, and sent to England’s notorious Broadmoor asylum. Much like British citizens at the time, readers are forced to resolve their feelings about Robert’s crimes with the man he becomes after his release—a war hero and upstanding member of his community.

The Feather Thief: Beauty, Obsession, and the Natural History Heist of the Century

By Kirk Wallace Johnson

Edwin Rist, obsessed with salmon fly-tying, couldn’t resist breaking into the British Museum of Natural History in 2009 and stealing its beautifully colored birds collected 150 years ago in the name of science. For a few years, he got away with his crime… at least, until Johnson decided to investigate. The result is The Feather Thief, the tale of a strangely exciting heist.

The Monster of Florence: A True Story

By Douglas Preston and Mario Spezi

Preston and his family move to Florence in 2000, but it isn’t the adventure they expect. When he meets Spezi, an investigative journalist, they set out to learn more about a local serial killer dubbed “The Monster of Florence,” even interviewing a man they think is the murderer. Their project goes horribly wrong when the police begin investigating them. Preston is thrown out of Italy, and Spezi is accused of being The Monster of Florence and thrown in prison! We don’t casually throw around the term “jaw-dropping,” but this story deserves it.

Smuggler's Blues: A True Story of the Hippie Mafia

By Richard Stratton

How did a buttoned-up college boy become one of the biggest drug smugglers in the country? Stratton shares the story of his incredible years spent smuggling weed and hashish around the world, rubbing elbows with everyone from David Bowie to Whitey Bulger, all while dodging a tireless DEA agent. It’s a fascinating look at both the war on drugs and a business that is gradually becoming decriminalized.

I'll Be Gone in the Dark: One Woman's Obsessive Search for the Golden State Killer

By Michelle McNamara

Northern California in the 1970s and 80s was in the grip of a serial rapist turned serial killer. With more than 160 crimes to his credit, identifying the Golden State Killer proved to be an epic logistical puzzle, but one that Michelle McNamara devoted years of her life to solving. And then, a tragedy within a tragedy: McNamara died of an accidental overdose in 2016. Her hard work lived on, and in February 2018, I’ll Be Gone was published. By April, the Golden State Killer was arrested.

Tangled Vines: Murder, Obsession, and an Arsonist in the Vineyards of California

By Frances Dinkelspiel

The 1800s saw vineyards that enslaved their workers and land owners murdered over partnerships that went sour.  In 2005, four and a half million bottles of wine went up in smoke at a storage warehouse. Dinkelspiel takes the long view of the many crimes that took place in California’s wine country for the sake of a grape—something to think about with your next glass of California red.

My Mother, a Serial Killer

By Hazel Baron and Janet Fife-Yeomans

Everyone in the town of Wilcannia (New South Wales, Australia) thinks Dulcie Baron is the perfect 1950s homemaker, baking scones and making tea for neighbors while raising her children alone, as a widow. What no one knows, until her daughter Hazel brings her to justice, is that Dulcie is a serial killer who has evaded police for decades after the murder of three men, including her husband. This is one family drama you won’t forget.

Mrs. Sherlock Holmes: The True Story of New York City's Greatest Female Detective and the 1917 Missing Girl Case That Captivated a Nation

By Brad Ricca

New York City high-society life was never a good fit for Grace Humiston, a lawyer-turned-detective who took the cases the police wouldn’t, in a time when women couldn’t vote. When Humiston accepted the case of missing teenager, Ruth Cruger, she found herself pitted against some of the most powerful men in the city as she methodically exposed a terrifying web of crimes and corruption. Today the question remains: What happened to Grace Humiston?

Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil

By John Berendt

Savannah, Georgia, is a small enough city that when a young man is murdered in a grand mansion in the middle of the night, there are plenty of people who have an opinion on how and why it happened, even ten years later. These are the voices Berendt captures in his blockbuster true-crime masterpiece as he rebuilds the life of the victim and his murderer, exposing the dark side of a sleepy, tight-knit town.

Unmasked

By Paul Holes

Detective Paul Holes is no stranger to looking evil in the eye. Across his decades-long career as a criminal investigator, he’s helped solve some of the most notorious cases in modern history, including the 20-year search for Joseph DeAngelo, aka the Golden State Killer. There’s plenty to be proud about, whether it’s the criminals he’s caught or the closure he’s provided to victims and their families—but it all came at a cost. In this eye-opening true crime memoir, Holes revisits the cases from his accomplished career and opens up about the toll they have taken on him and his family. If you’re a true crime reader who’s curious about the lives behind the badge, this one’s for you.

Bad City: Peril and Power in the City of Angels

By Paul Pringle

Life moves fast in the City of Angels, so when L.A. Times reporter Paul Pringle receives a tip about a suspicious drug overdose at a fancy hotel nearby, he figures it won’t take long to sort out. Little does he know that he’s about to uncover a web of crime and cover-ups that twists across Los Angeles, from the elite halls of the University of Southern California to the author’s own doorstep. Pulitzer Prize–winner Pringle delivers an incredible piece of investigative journalism in Bad City, serving up a gripping true crime narrative that reads like a simmering L.A. noir novel.

Last Call

By Elon Green

This Edgar Award–winning book investigates the lesser-known crimes of the Last Call Killer, a serial murderer who terrorized New York City’s queer community in the ’80s and ’90s. Though the Last Call Killer claimed multiple lives, his murders received little media coverage. Even today, the crimes are rarely discussed compared to some of the other high-profile cases on this list. Why is that? Green examines how the victims’ sexuality combined with New York’s staggering homicide rate and the AIDS epidemic led to this case nearly being lost to time. Last Call is a powerful true crime book that puts the lives of the victims first, remembering those who were lost and championing the strength and resilience of their community. It also doubles as an ideal next pick for your true crime book club.

Share with your friends

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest

Related Articles

There’s no escaping these captivating reads with remote island settings — but then again, why would you ever want to leave?
Need a captivating new nonfiction narrative for your history book club? The following history books span the centuries, presenting fascinating true-life accounts from WWII-era survival sagas and rousing portraits of unsung American heroes to world-changing episodes from our distant past. They’re certain to inspire plenty of discussion among your history book club crew about the momentous events of yesteryear and what we can learn from them today.
The following photography books offer an astonishing visual journey through the American landscape, presenting indelible moments of heartbreak, triumph, and survival.

Connect with

Celadon

Sign up for our newsletter to see book giveaways, news, and more!