Books to Read if You Loved The Maidens

By Brandon Miller
A collection of three intriguing novels showcased against a dual-toned background, each featuring distinct and artistic cover designs that hint at the mysteries contained within their pages.

These propulsive reads will keep you on the edge of your seat, just like Alex Michaelides’ latest thriller.

Alex Michaelides’ The Maidens is an electrifying psychological thriller packed with compelling characters and shocking plot twists. The bestselling narrative centers on a secret society of female students at Cambridge University and one woman’s obsessive search for the truth after a member of the group turns up dead.

The novel was a hit when it was published in 2021, and if you’ve just finished reading it, you’re likely searching for more mysterious tales to pick up next. Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered. Here are eight thrilling books like The Maidens that are ready to be cracked open.

A book cover of "the silent patient" by alex michaelides, featuring a partial face with lips sealed, hinting at the theme of silence or secrecy.

The Silent Patient

By Alex Michaelides

Fans of The Maidens should definitely check out Alex Michaelides’ debut novel, The Silent Patient. Both are dark psychological thrillers with vibrant characters and shocking twists. They also draw on Greek myths to tell their gripping tales. In The Maidens, a Cambridge student’s murder sets off a baffling campus mystery. In The Silent Patient, criminal psychotherapist Theo Faber is determined to understand why a famous painter named Alicia Berenson brutally shot her husband — and why she now refuses to speak.

Cover of.Korelitz's book The Plot, which features a blue background with a white book and text THE PLOT superimposed onto the image

The Plot

By Jean Hanff Korelitz

Both The Maidens and The Plot are dark academia books, which makes them perfect companion pieces. The Maidens focuses on a secret campus society and a potentially dangerous Greek tragedy professor by the name of Edward Fosca. In The Plot, Jean Hanff Korelitz introduces us to a different kind of professor — one with dubious ethical boundaries. When washed-up writing teacher Jacob Finch Bonner discovers that his former student passed away before finishing a promising novel, Bonner decides to take the plot and pass it off as his own. Years later, an ominous e-mail threatens to destroy Bonner’s revived career. Now the professor must confront his fateful choice and uncover the stolen narrative’s true origins before it’s too late.

The Secret Place by Tana French

The Secret Place

By Tana French

Like Alex Michaelides, Tana French is a New York Times bestselling author and a master at crafting dark tales of suspense. And like The Maidens, The Secret Place takes place in an academic environment. This time, it’s a boarding school for girls, where a boy has been murdered. A year later, the murder remains unsolved. When a new clue prompts the reopening of the case, a team of detectives — including Frank Mackey, the father of a student at the school — must uncover the truth. Fans of The Maidens’ dark and elegant style will love this gem of a novel.

Cover of the book "case histories" by kate atkinson, the first novel featuring the character jackson brodie.

Case Histories

By Kate Atkinson

Like The Maidens, Case Histories boasts an intricate narrative that draws you in and doesn’t let you go until the last page is turned. The book centers on Jackson Brodie, a private detective who’s investigating three seemingly unrelated cases. The first incident occurred some 30 years ago, when a little girl went missing in the middle of the night. Now Brodie must figure out how the decades-old disappearance connects to one mother’s shocking fit of rage and an apparently random attack on a young office worker.

A cover of a suspense novel titled "the ancient nine" by ian k. smith, suggesting a thrilling story about secrets and mysteries, likely set in an academic or historical backdrop.

The Ancient Nine

By Ian K. Smith

Ian K. Smith’s The Ancient Nine is sure to appeal to readers who enjoyed The Maidens’ focus on cloak-and-dagger cliques. Like Michaelides’ novel, Smith’s tale dives into the dark rituals of a shadowy secret society. Harvard students Spenser Collins and Dalton Winthrop have just been tapped to join the ultra-elite campus group known as the Delphic Club. The invite is too good to pass up. Yet the more they look into the club, the more alarming questions they unearth and the closer they get to the Ancient Nine, a mysterious group of all-powerful alums who will do whatever it takes to keep their secrets hidden.

Ariadne by Jennifer Saint


By Jennifer Saint

Greek mythology plays a key role in The Maidens, given that Greek tragedy professor Edward Fosca is obsessed with the rites of Persephone and her journey to the underworld. Jennifer Saint also draws on Greek mythology to forge her beguiling tale. Her novel follows Ariadne, princess of Crete, and her quest to overcome her brother, a monster known as the Minotaur. With the help of Theseus, Prince of Athens, Ariadne takes on the monster. But her decision to betray her blood has fateful consequences.

The Burning Girls by CJ Tudor

The Burning Girls

By C.J. Tudor

The Burning Girls is as terrifying as it is exciting, striking a tone similar to that of The Maidens. It centers on Rev. Jack Brooks, who moves to Chapel Croft, a remote village with a sordid history and a cast of unusual residents. When the reverend and his teenage daughter receive an ominous welcome package, it becomes clear that there’s more going on in this village than meets the eye. The Burning Girls is steeped in the supernatural, yet at its heart, it’s a tale about history, secrecy, and conspiracies — perfect for any fan of The Maidens.

Share with your friends


Related Articles

These revelatory reads are sure to expand your mind.
These books capture the highs, lows, and boundless joys of fatherhood and the father–child bond.
Curiosity seekers, unite: If you love listening to Radiolab or binge-watching entire seasons of Nova, these mesmerizing science books are for you.

Celadon delivered

Subscribe to get articles about writing, adding to your TBR pile, and simply content we feel is worth sharing. And yes, also sign up to be the first to hear about giveaways, our acquisitions, and exclusives!

Two compact discs (CDs) with shiny, reflective surfaces are overlapping each other on a white background. The discs display a spectrum of colors due to the light reflection, creating a rainbow-like effect.

"*" indicates required fields

Step 1 of 8

Who would you rather spend time with?*

Connect with


Sign up for our newsletter to see book giveaways, news, and more!